Sweettttt. Also, I apologize, the Hobbit is out
next week.
wrote:Frozen?
Better that Tangled?
From the trailer, it looked a bit like a rip-off, with very similar mannerisms
Well that was one of the big issues people had with the movie. Rapunzel and the two leads of Frozen have pretty much identical facial designs. The lead animator's response to the very legitimate criticism was basically "you don't understanddddd, animating women is really harddddd you have to keep them pretty but still have them go through a wide range of emotion" which was just screwed up on so many levels.
One of the first rules of character design is that if everyone looks the same with a hair and palate swap
you are a bad designer. It's part of the reason my drawings for Lockwood and Bartimaeus are taking so long, I want to have some variety. For the company that pretty much invented feature animation it's quite disappointing. Plus it's tied into Hollywood's awful "all women have to fit in a very narrow appearance range for us to care about them" standard.
But Disney's marketing model right now seems to be based on "if it works once, repeat until it stops working" which is why promotionally the film looks so similar to Tangled, and why they pretty much gutted their 2D department (still upset about that). Looking at some of the early concept art people posted, apparently the designs
weren't always so similar.
Storywise however I don't see many similarities. Which is good because I
actually didn't like Tangled as much as everyone else seems to. And I probably liked the costuming and environment design better than anything else in the movie (there is a back part of my brain that just keeps going "so many colours, so pretty")
(People have also brought up various race and gender issues in regards to the film; I won't go into those because frankly I don't have much expertise on the subject and I don't want to misrepresent anyone.)
Oh look I wrote an essay again. Heh just ignore me.
![]()
FOUNDER OF THE SAM THE BARMAN FANCLUB: QUOTE IN YOUR SIG TO JOIN