rubberchickenben Marid
23 Dec 09 - 05:16
Yay for SH.
I wish I were a cat-dragon
but Robert Downey Jr is sooooooooooooooo funnyAsmoral_The_Resolute wrote:Does no-one agree that Sherlock Holmes shouldn't be an arse kicking wise cracking american?
Actually more accurate to the books than most movie portrayals. Well, minus the American bit. But I'd rather ask the English folks we have here as to the accuracy of the accent.Asmoral wrote:Does no-one agree that Sherlock Holmes shouldn't be an arse kicking wise cracking american?
What's with Holmes boxing?Sentynel wrote:I've not seen enough bits of the movie to judge the accent, but I do know that things notably absent from the Sherlock Holmes books include explosions, big action sequences, and Guy Ritchie.
I think there's an offhand mention in A Study in Scarlet that Holmes can box, but it's never brought up again.Nero wrote:What's with Holmes boxing?Sentynel wrote:I've not seen enough bits of the movie to judge the accent, but I do know that things notably absent from the Sherlock Holmes books include explosions, big action sequences, and Guy Ritchie.
No matter how true to the book it is, this will make it more awesome.Sentynel wrote:I've not seen enough bits of the movie to judge the accent, but I do know that things notably absent from the Sherlock Holmes books include explosions, big action sequences, and Guy Ritchie.
That's why I like LotR as much as I didApollo wrote:I think you have to see the Sherlock Holmes movie keeping in mind that it will slaughter the books, and you can't pretend to be disappointed when it does.
