i'd go for mandrake. :D

Whitwell would crush him.

Nah, Nat (at the time of PG, remember) had more standby forces, and could summon new ones just as fast as Whitewell.

Whitewell would have beaten Mandrake easily during the time of PG because she can summon "higher quality " slaves than him in the same period of time. ;) Though I think that if Mandrake had survived, he could eventually be stronger than her. :)

Welcome then!

Cookie is miine

Jessica Whitwell would win. Mandrake is talented but she is lots more experienced and probably won't be too bothered that she'll be killing her ex-ward. Maybe in another few years.

Whitwell would win unless Mandrake was possessed with Barti (I had no clue how that happened) and wielding the staff

"Possessed with party?"

*dies laughing*

Asmoral_The_Resolute wrote:Whitwell would win unless Mandrake was possessed with party and wielding the staff

I had the same reaction lol. So would Nat be so crazy from partying that he randomly fires the staff and manages to kill Whitwell and (probably) himself?


Ok enough being a jerk, i'm done laughing now.

FuzzyLobster wrote:"Possessed with party?"

*dies laughing*

Truly, that is a typo win.

look I mean B and P are so far away from each other, HOW DID THAT HAPPEN!!!

Subconsiously. The dark depths of your brain did it for some entertainment.

Wow, mine got ressurected.
Probably Whitewell, unless John has his assortment in PG, before they were wiped out by Faquarl.

but if faquarl could do all of that then imagine what Shubit could do to them

This! ^

True.
But if he can handle a handful of djinn at a time, I'm sure he could rustle up some afrit(s) of his own.

depends on who he summons, we aren't told quite how powerful an afrit Shubit is but were led to believe he is at the higher end of the spectrum.

also does Whitwell have access to all the artifacts in the tower of London?

Yes, but if so, so would John. When I asked this, I meant 1 on 1 with whatever they have, not counting items.
If either had the staff and could control it, no contest. Probably.
'Less someone gets around... whatever.
Nonetheless, Whitewell's afrit is probably hi-end, enough to give Nouda pause, at the very least. John's djinn probably wouldn't be enough, if Honorious is anything to go by.
So, would John be able to summon a significant Afrit? Two?

Yeah, I think he would be capable. It is a tough contest. Jessica has got experience on her side though. So she might win. if given a few years, Nathaniel might. Child prodigy.
Your post made me think what would happen if Nathaniel and Jessica were made to fight without spirits assisting them. No summoning. It is fun to visualize them scratching & pulling at each other =D. I don't think either of them is capable of delivering a blow.