were the chars really under developed and snotty(i dont normaly use that word but we cant curse so um yah) <_<

the golems eye was the book that most people disliked... i think it was the new charactors. When i re-read that book i found it quite hard to get into it...i think the first time round i was desperate for it...

b.t.w you can say crap... but none of the stronger swear words :P

William Gladstone wrote: the golems eye was the book that most people disliked... i think it was the new charactors. When i re-read that book i found it quite hard to get into it...i think the first time round i was desperate for it...

b.t.w you can say crap... but none of the stronger swear words :P

iwasnt going to use crap...it was a tas bit stronger..like biotch(please lets us be allowed to say that)....except not conformed to be more less vulgar

thats fine :o

yes

I liked the characters more in GE and thought they were developed more. For example, Stroud developed Nathaniel by essentially making him degress as a person into Pure Snottiness. And Barty was as interesting as ever.

i know but the snottieness was some thing i would expct maybe in th e third book but not in the second...

yeah, I did NOT like nathaniel in the second book!!!!!!!! he is probably one of the only main charactets in a book that i realy didnt like....

Yea Natty was just..... to into himself, with all the grooming and the cuffs (id love to see those in real life)

Jane Farrar was REALLY nice when she had the Charm/Glamour on.

Barti, you gotta love him

So Nathaniel was snotty. It's different from any other book. It'd be cliche if he turned into a complete goody goody like all of the other fantasy serieses

but he is only acting like all magicians do

i wasn t expecting him to mimic them so soon

I wasn't expecting him to change so much either, but I guess in an environment like that you WOULD start to comform to society quite a bit...

...if only there's been more Bartimaeus chapters...but I have to say, my favorite part was the chapters with Barti and Kitty talking. Twas very interesting...yet ANOTHER thing I'm looking forward to seeing in Ptolemy's Gate, more scenes with Barti and Kitty talking to each other...

there are some good ones in it!

.:William Gladstone:. wrote: there are some good ones in it!

Really and truly? :D Huzzah!

Barty is my favorite character! I could actually see myself playing him, as that Egyptian boy. I look close enough

I really didnt like Kitty and her story.

I think it was good :P

think what you want....

i liked it as wel, infact i am re-reading that book now!