Doktor Butters (probably the best username ever. ) Oh and, thanks for ruining fight club for me...(just kidding, I didn't actually read that part).

Back on topic: As much as I want Nat to come back, I agree that that would probably ruin the ending. It was probably the best way to end it, really...

And Blieze ( as well by the way) i agree with the part about Harry Potter (I would quote it, but I can't right now). Don't get me wrong, I like happy endings (and love the books to death) but the ending just seemed so... unrealistic.

That was a bit of a long winded post...

FuzzyLobster wrote:Don't get me wrong, I like happy endings (and love the books to death) but the ending just seemed so... unrealistic.

You mean the end when Harry finally defeats Voldemort, or the epilogue? Cause the epilogue did seem kinda cheesy.

As for the part where Voldemort gets defeated, I could say it could have been a bit better...but go Mrs. Weasley!

[+] Spoiler

Both really. I know it sounds morbid, but I was expecting a lot of people to die, especially considering the situation. But no, despite facing experienced, ruthless murders, most of the characters (and with the exception of Fred and Colin, all of the young, inexperienced wizards) survive without any major injury and go on to have a million children...

Whoa! How'd you do that? Like This?
No...

[*this?][/li]

Do you mean the spoiler tags?

Look at the last one

Oh, geez, I didn't even realize you can actually do that until now...

HogwartsHokage slaps palm on forehead

-_-

I knew pretty much everything except for background colouring and spoilers.
Oh...there it is...

I think the spoilers thing came new with the upgrade...

Most forums do have them...

I don't think I'd want Nat to come back all that much. I mean it would be nice in some ways, but not so nice in others.

I would hate it.

Won't happen, get used to it.

I was sad when Nat died, but him sacrificing himself, at the end, made the book really amazing (not that Nat needed to die to make the trilogy amazing, but u get wat i mean).
And if he came back, it would ruin the ending of PG.

Still won't happen.

Dansariki wrote:Still won't happen.

I'm sure that's what crazy meant....

Lol, no its not gonna happen.

Vinr Alfakyn wrote:I don't think I'd want Nat to come back all that much. I mean it would be nice in some ways, but not so nice in others.

I totally agree..... ^o)

of course. so that the trilogy can continue. :D

sharingansaber wrote:of course. so that the trilogy can continue. :D

Then it won't be called a trilogy.

And would ruin the former trilogy, imo.

Just like Inheritance.

Yes, but at this would be after-the-fact, and that would screw it royally up.
Duology-Trilogy-Tetrology

I know Kitty & Bart might want Nat back(& the kinder part of me agrees), but Nat coming back alive would totally ruin the brilliant ending & the trilogy as a whole.