Gladstone wrote: I Gave it a 10.....

Loved this book.


:post:

huh???!!i cant vote on it...anyways i would give it a 10...or a 100..orr a 1000...oh yu can get what i mean..i loVE the book!the whole trilogy rox....

can't vote but would give 10. almost the best book ever written

9.5 ..nat shouldnt have died xD

I can't vote but I would give it a ten....Although it was really sad that Nat died I can't think of a better way to end the series...

9.5. I would have given it a ten but Nat died....right when i finally really liked him!!! Made me soooooooooooooooooooooooo sad.

LOVED THE ENDING!!!! nice fast-paced plot tooo

i gave it a 10

10 for 10, Stroud. The apex of fantasy writing. And I'm NOT exaggerating.

I didn't get to vote, but I like the Golem's Eye better anyhow.

It was amazing. It even made me cry in the end, but that's why it's so good.

5/5

Best-flushed out, great ending, great sense of tension throughout, and masterful handling of Makepeace.

Ten fo sho!! It seems like I'm the only one who liked that Nat died. He was a jerk in the second book. But the fact that he died and sacrificed his life in the end and even released Bartimaeus instead of taking Bart with him was selfless!! So Therefore I like Nat now, for he is a true hero in giving up his life for the good of the good.

gave it 10/10! LOVED THIS BOOK!

I was sooooo upset when Nathaniel died, but if he had lived it would have been totally bogus. A happily-ever-after would nearly ruin the trilogy.

I gave it 10/10 because there was no option to give it 1,000,000.

Stroud did a superb job of writing it, and the whole book seemed to flow the best out of the entire trilogy. I can't think of a more suitable ending because it's powerful enough to stick with readers for a long time afterwards, whilst pulling a few heart-strings and giving the trilogy a satisfying sense of completeness :)

I WOULD have given it a 10, but Kitty annoyed me too much...

Queezle7 wrote:but I like the Golem's Eye better anyhow.

I agree.

aiReY-chan wrote:It was amazing. It even made me cry in the end, but that's why it's so good.

I was extremely teary eyed at the end myself :'(


I gave it a big 10!

I give the entire trilogy a 10!

Best book series I've ever read!

I'm giving it a BIG 10!!

This book is the best of the three, but I love all the books! Yay!

An epic ending by an epic author. Not all authors can pull such a good ending as that. And with one of the main characters dying, too. He must be really good. No, he's REALLY good.

Nothing but the best for the best! ;)

I gave it a solid 10.
The best book from the best trilogy from all the books i've ever read :D :wub:

Who the hell is the bastards who gave it under 3?!?!!? This is a disgrace!

Someone should find out who it was and dish out severe repercussions.