I gave it under 3 to teach the internet a lesson for not letting me vote 10

Yes, but we are getting more.

Yes we most defieneitly are! :krim:

I gave it a 9.5. Now that I think about it I should have given't it a ten, but oh well.

I can't remember the rating I gave it. Odd. I need a better memory.

Mwamba wrote:I can't remember the rating I gave it. Odd. I need a better memory.

You need a better memory? I can't even remember what I voted on the "which bio's better" poll! And that was like yesterday!

I can't remember a lot of what I say from day to day...so yeah.

I voted 9.5 I admit I almost cried at the end where Nat died.. o_O

I cried and dreamed about it and woke up crying.

I'm an emotionally fragile person.

Haha...*yay* for callousness.

o_O Ok, so you cried. Well, don't you ship Nat/Death?

I rated an 8.5 for this book. It has an awesome story, but during most of the book, bartimaeus has been depleted of much of his essence, and he doesn't get into any fights! Still on the whole, this book was awesome! ;)

9.5. best book in the trilogy, in my opinion.

The ending is okay, but it could be better. Why, WHY did Nathaniel have to die! :(
And the thing with kitty is sort of incomplete, because we want to know what happens next.

neville wrote: during most of the book, bartimaeus has been depleted of much of his essence, and he doesn't get into any fights!

I agree that this lowered my rating for the book. I think I'm a sort of literary tomboy, I love brawls and violent scenes in my fiction. =D

Exactly.

Well Tycho Brahe's nose got cut off, that's a brawl. Or was that in this book? No, it was in Golem's Eye , I think...

I can't vote!!
But I would say 10!! :krim:

I gave it 9.5 because it was near perfect, although Nathaniel should have taken on the role of William Gladstone with the staff and re-conquer America and Europe, to stop the fighting and the endless war in America, then have the big showdown with Nouda.

Why can't you vote, Yakaii?