Luciene Higher Spirit
2 Feb 08 - 21:26
You read twillight?
It was like 34854654534354 million pages!!!!
I'm so proud of you bb
It was like 34854654534354 million pages!!!!
I'm so proud of you bb
haha, i take it you're a fan then? not surprising since i'm used to being outnumbered by them on any given site i visit. not that it's a bad thing though, as i haven't yet talked to a twilight fan that wasn't open-minded. i usually come across comment like your next one:Mwamba wrote:Woah, somebody who hates Twilight *uncomprehending*
i can tolerate that stuff as long as the characters are interesting enough. people like her because they can relate to her, but i found bella lacking in personality. edward was a gary-stu/wish-fulfillment character, and meyer shoves it down our throats. my english teacher would say it's 'authorial interpolation', where the author tells us how we're supposed to feel. i hate it to death, and it usually makes me feel the opposite, because i like to make up my own opinion. i hate Ginny in HP for the same reason. in any given story, the characters are usually my favourite part, so if it weren't for that i'd be reading them compulsively despite other shortfalls.wrote:Admittedly, it's not that great, true. There is too much melodrama and the plot is kinda bland. But it's still so...addicting.

(disclaimer: this is all my pure biased opinion that may or may not make sense) Exactly what makes the story so popular. Edward appeals to many wish-fufillment fantasies. Bella loves to read, and well, if you love Twilight, chances are you're not very averse to reading yourself. Bella is oh so insecure about herself, and many females are very insecure about themselves and would love to have a inhumanely hot guy fascinated by them and tell them how truly wonderful and beautiful they really are. I mean, the story is told in first person. I think the 'lack of personality' works in Meyer's favor her. It makes it easier for a girl to imagine herself as Bella, maybe.wrote: people like her because they can relate to her, but i found bella lacking in personality. edward was a gary-stu/wish-fulfillment character, and meyer shoves it down our throats
Don't know what you mean by that. It's not like Meyer took a break halfway through the book and started ranting about blueberries or anything. :Pwrote: My theory is the longer the book, the worse it gets, as the author loses sight of the book's true goal.
it's virtually unknown in my school, though for how long i don't know. i don't mind fangirling, but not when i can't go three posts without someone drooling over edward, but not saying what else made them love the book. i always wonder, if you asked those people their favourite part of the story aside from edward's sooperness, or bella's relatable-ness, would you get a decent answer? or are they just reading it to drool/self-insert? that's just a small percentage of fans, though.wrote:Lol, true. Everyone I know who's read it is in love with the story. I mostly hear 'ZOMG I LOVE EDWARD!' and 'ZOMG I EFFING HATE JACOB'
i thought the very same. but that doesn't stop it from irritating me... writing an interesting character that has flaws but is still likable, takes more time and effort than a Gary-Sue like edward. yet there are so many great, imaginative stories out there, like Bart Trilogy, with awesome plots and (flawed) characters, that are way better but only half as popular as twilight. but i do realise i'm very critical, and understand the appeal of twilight to people who aren't as harsh as me lol.wrote:(disclaimer: this is all my pure biased opinion that may or may not make sense) Exactly what makes the story so popular. Edward appeals to many wish-fufillment fantasies. Bella loves to read, and well, if you love Twilight, chances are you're not very averse to reading yourself. Bella is oh so insecure about herself, and many females are very insecure about themselves and would love to have a inhumanely hot guy fascinated by them and tell them how truly wonderful and beautiful they really are. I mean, the story is told in first person. I think the 'lack of personality' works in Meyer's favor her. It makes it easier for a girl to imagine herself as Bella, maybe.
i didn't read the last two... i asked a twilight fan if it got any better for people who found the characters irritating, just to see if i should continue. she said no, so i threw in the towel.wrote:I find the majority of the characters likable, except for Bella and Edward when they become cringingly over-the-top. (Well, Jacob did too, bad that was just cuz he was trying to court Bella in book three, so I can blame her.)
