Unfortunately, i didnt have time last night to write a good enough response.

You broke the rules, we punished you.

You obviously think the rules are over the top.

Lets look at the gateworld.net forum. Do they have the same tight restrictions on flaming as us? Yes. Does any go on none the less? No. Is there a good atmosphere on the forum? Yes - the gateworld forum is the best stargate forum on the net.

Lets look at Kenny's forum RUGE. Do they have the same tight restrictions on flaming as us? Yes. Does any go on none the less? No. Is there a good atmosphere on the forum? Yes.

I rest my case.

Krim, i wont have any of your unessesary flaming on this site. I want this forum to be for people to discuss the books in the nice friendly way. Has anyone else been breaking the rules? No.

To be honest, i couldnt care less what you think about the forum, and the rules, but while you are here, you will obide by them, and hay, you are here out of choice, i'm not forcing you to come - So if you hate the rules that much, the leave, see if i care.

I also couldnt care less if youve written the most fantastic book in the world, i dont care if you are Jesus. But you will obide to the rules.

Respond however you want, but i will not continue this pointless discussion, we are here to talk about the bartimaeus trilogy, not your views on the rules.

WGladstone