Satisfied with the way Bellatrix died?

Book Discussion
R u satisfied with the way Bella died? I surely am not! She tortured Neville's parents, killed Sirius, Dobby, Tonks. Did she kill Fred too? If so....................
And Hedwig??? I have a bad feeling she killed her too. And how did she die? By a killing curse! Ugh. Sirius died the same way she did. Did they both deserve the same death? No way! I sat till one yesterday thinking of the ways she ought to have died. Torture her till she loses her mind, cut her into a thousand peices, boil the peices & feed the mixture into the mouths of starving Blast Ended Skwerts.

And did she really die? Some say she was just stunned or pushed away. That's what she did to Sirius they say. And he fell into the arc & died.

Poor George! Do u think he would crack another joke? Jo said he had'nt got over Fred's death even after 19 long years! He's the character I feel most sorry for. Losing Fred would have been like losing a big part of himself or worse. However we don't get to see his reaction in the book. I think Jo wanted to keep it open for discussions. How do u think he would have reacted. Would he have cracked another joke or ever be funny again? Don't u think Fred might have come back for him as a ghost? Solely for him? I would have surely done it if I had a twin like George.
"If the bee disappears from the surface of the earth, man would have no more than four years to live. No more bees, no more pollination ... no more men!" - Einstein
"I like quoting Einstein. Know why? Because nobody dares contradict you." - Studs Terkel.
<@Ximenez> Sentynel: But i have a life? No. Qed.
User Avatar
Queezle7 Horla
grrrr bellatrix.
she was really well played in the movie.
no, i don't think george will ever be quite the same again.
though maybe fred will come back as a ghost.
Look, Queezle.
User Avatar
Mwamba Higher Spirit
nathanielandbartimaeus wrote: R u satisfied with the way Bella died?
Nope. If the coolest character in the book was going to die, it should have at least been by Neville. He spent seven years developing as a character and in the end turned into an awesome bad ass, Molly...blah.

And Bella is supposed to be 'a woman with formidable strength and no conscience.' She would have gotten Ginny if her full energy was focused on her (screw you JK.)

*Sigh* I hate Molly just as much as I hate Ginny. Both are just boring characters who randomly become so amazing (and I can hear JK screaming 'LOVE THEM, THEY ARE WONDERFUL behind them) and I'm supposed to care. *scoff*

As for George, *shrug.* Didn't touch me, I'm sorry.

Just remember why DH is awesome though: AS/S.
&#27969;&#21475;&#27700;&#30340;&#23114;&#23376;&#21644;&#29492;&#23376;&#30340;&#31528;&#20799;&#23376;&#12290;
Nectanebo Foliot
AS/S?

I reckon Neville should've killed her. It would've definitely made more sense that way.

Oh, and Mwamba, you are such a hypocrite. If what made Bella cool was her cruelty, your reasons for hating Ginny are utter BS. Ignore the second sentence if you have a better reason for liking Bella.
User Avatar
Mwamba Higher Spirit
I don't hate Ginny for being supposedly nice, I hate her for being a two dimensional Mary Sue. :)

Bella has style. It's not so much her cruelety, it's the way she carries herself while she's being cruel. She makes evil look good. It's hard to explain, but she's captivating, even though JK's intent for her was supposed to be the character you hate. (But I'm also probably supposed to adore Ginny, so blah.)

AS/S is Albus Severus/Scoprius. Both are born with crappy names, and they can make up for their fathers who were too chicken to get together. It's a wonderful OTP.
&#27969;&#21475;&#27700;&#30340;&#23114;&#23376;&#21644;&#29492;&#23376;&#30340;&#31528;&#20799;&#23376;&#12290;
User Avatar
Athena Horla
Bellatrix was one of the better characters in the book. I didn't like that she died at all, though I do like that she linked her death with Sirius.

I am still mourning Fred. R.I.P
There is a sort of busy worm,
That will the fairest book deform,
Their tasteless tooth will tear and taint
The poet, patiot,sage or saint,
Nor sparing wit nor learning.
Now, if you'd know the reason why,
The best of reasons I'll supply;
'Tis bread to this poor vermin.

J. Doraston
We all are. I hated how he was caught off gaurd! And died smiling . . . so sad!!! :cry:
Vinr Alfakyn wrote: We all are. I hated how he was caught off gaurd! And died smiling . . . so sad!!! :cry:
Three people died laughing. Sirius, Fred, Bellatrix. It almost seems to me that laughing during a battle is fatal.
Harry seems to like girls who r popular, pretty & good quidditch players. Cho & Ginny r standing examples.
"If the bee disappears from the surface of the earth, man would have no more than four years to live. No more bees, no more pollination ... no more men!" - Einstein
"I like quoting Einstein. Know why? Because nobody dares contradict you." - Studs Terkel.
<@Ximenez> Sentynel: But i have a life? No. Qed.
User Avatar
Queezle7 Horla
Oh horror.
I bet Harry's the first guy to ever like girls who are pretty, popular, and good at sports.
Harry/Ginny is actually rather realistic.
Besides, I love them both.
Look, Queezle.
User Avatar
Mwamba Higher Spirit
Ginny will curse people just because they simply annoy her with her 'famous bat boogey hex.' (And if it's famous, it must mean she does a lot of damage. She needs anger management, not be considered 'cute' because of it.)

What's so special about her to make her Harry's soulmate? And her popularity springs out of nowhere, we only knew she's popular because JK had to say it outright.

&#27969;&#21475;&#27700;&#30340;&#23114;&#23376;&#21644;&#29492;&#23376;&#30340;&#31528;&#20799;&#23376;&#12290;
User Avatar
Athena Horla
But don't you see Mwamba? She's 'fiesty'. Every guy wants a girl who's got 'spirit'.
There is a sort of busy worm,
That will the fairest book deform,
Their tasteless tooth will tear and taint
The poet, patiot,sage or saint,
Nor sparing wit nor learning.
Now, if you'd know the reason why,
The best of reasons I'll supply;
'Tis bread to this poor vermin.

J. Doraston
User Avatar
Mwamba Higher Spirit
*Sigh.*
&#27969;&#21475;&#27700;&#30340;&#23114;&#23376;&#21644;&#29492;&#23376;&#30340;&#31528;&#20799;&#23376;&#12290;
User Avatar
Queezle7 Horla
Athena wrote: But don't you see Mwamba? She's 'fiesty'. Every guy wants a girl who's got 'spirit'.
Darn it. I'm doomed to be an old spinster with cats.
Not really. But hey, I'm not spunky and I like Ginny.
Look, Queezle.
User Avatar
Athena Horla
Whats wrong with cats? :P
There is a sort of busy worm,
That will the fairest book deform,
Their tasteless tooth will tear and taint
The poet, patiot,sage or saint,
Nor sparing wit nor learning.
Now, if you'd know the reason why,
The best of reasons I'll supply;
'Tis bread to this poor vermin.

J. Doraston
I wish I were a cat-dragon
I luv my cats. Specially Simba. :wub: He has an unwholsome attraction to tennis balls. :D

Add Reply