All I'm saying is just keep the fanon to fanfiction. (As in, Nathaniel is and always will be dead. Unless he can reincarnate to Kian or something. :P)

Edit: And the books describes his lack of body. Kitty went out there herself looking for him and she couldn't find him. And Nat certainly wasn't in a condition to be mobile. And so, he incinerated and just became a pile of ash.

NATHANIEL IS DEAD!!

Phoenix wrote:

wrote: What more confirmation can you need than getting completely incinerated and then crushed?

The book describes his body, does it?

It describes an explosion which would reduce his body to dust, and a staggering lack of teleportation.

I think if a building fell on you, a fire burned you, you had about a million injuries, and someone swallowed you, you would be dead.

Oh and Fanon and Canon are actually surprisingly separate things.

Phoenix wrote: Do you now? Canon is what is confirmed in the books. If it isn't confirmed beyond the shadow of a miniscule doubt in the books, it's not canon.

According to the official lexicon of terms, Canon is:

wrote: Facts that have been told to us in the books and in interviews with the author.

This is all Stroud said about Nat.

He said that so far, Dial Up Sucks is dead.

Edit:

Ok there, at first I accidenally typed in "Net" so I edited it to "Dial Up Sucks" and when I did, it replaced "Dial Up Sucks" with "Dial Up Sucks". Why did it do that?

Edit: Ok, the last bit was a test. Why is N A T now, "Dial Up Sucks"?

Since when are explosions and falling buildings lethal in fiction?

Artemis wrote: Edit: Ok, the last bit was a test. Why is N A T now, "Dial Up Sucks"?

Founder's Week amusement. Various name replacement.


Explosions and falling buildings are always fatal without a convenient deus ex machina to get out of it, which Nate lacks.

And a huge gash in his side, too.

wrote:Explosions and falling buildings are always fatal without a convenient deus ex machina to get out of it, which Nate lacks.

What if we never saw the convenient deus ex machina?

wrote:And a huge gash in his side, too.

... that's not insurmountable.

Phoenix wrote:

wrote:Explosions and falling buildings are always fatal without a convenient deus ex machina to get out of it, which Nate lacks.

What if we never saw the convenient deus ex machina?

Cos, you know, Nate had a teleporter device, which doesn't even exist, hidden in his back pocket...

Exactly! See? A convert.

Convert?

It's called "sarcasm" my dear.

wrote:It's called "sarcasm" my dear.

Your explanations fall on deaf ears.

I think it should be another book in the same World, with Barti as main caracther.

Just without the other characters perhaps. That might screw up my mental picture of them.

Adele wrote: I would like to see bartimaeus return, but not with Kitty, maybe with some other random magician/person who doesn't know about the "incident".

Yeh! Some one new who doesn't know about the "incident". That would be great!

What about a prequel series about Bart's past adventures?

If the new book is in the same timeline, then how about a story about barti's new master somewhere far off, detailing the effects and the probable worldwide upheavle after after all this happened. Yes i know i spelled it wrong. <_<

Same poeple [yes naty] same place same things!








:(

He should make o new book because the ending leaves me hanging. I mean, He should continue it at least with Kitty in it rather than end the series indefinatly.

First of all, evry 1 thinks Bart died w/ nat. In the summoning books he will be put down as a dead troublesome djinni. nats final gift: never being summoned again.

And i think the next one should be a history af all barts heroic exploits. A sort of autobiography. :D