Ebele Mite
6 Feb 09 - 10:35
First of all I absolutely LOVED the books! They are my all time favorites! Thank you so much for writing them!
Well, to business.
Amanda, is she a magician, or a commoner?
In the end of AoS Bartimaeus took her guise and tricked Lovelace, we all know that. But in the beginning, when Bart was stealing the amulet he dwelled on taking N's guise but said that he needs the person's birth name to become them, this is how he becomes Ptolemy and Kitty later on. So if 'Amanda' was her real name, that means she can't be a magician, but how can she be a commoner if she's rich? I mean, she's having this big party at her place, and all the cool kids from the government are invited... what's up with that? Why would the PM go to a ball in a commoner's house? Also, if she is a commoner, why would Lovelace be with her?
So who is she?
By the way, I live in Israel, and I know theres a Hebrew translation but I still read the books in English, the original is far better I always say, with the true touch of the author. Yep, and also, (as far as I know) your books are not very well known in Israel, at least, Im the only one who read them in my school and weve got this book report we have to do in English, so naturally Im doing mine on AoS, (my fav), other kids are just taking books form the school library. Ive asked around and saw that all the other kids think this report is torture because the only English books our library has are kitsch romantic novels written like, a hundred years ago(!) nothing against old novels, its just not very suitable for non English speaker kids. So I recommended Bartimaeus trilogy and the library bought it! So now Im happy and I just thought you might want to know Im doing some advertisement for you here :D spreading the word!
Yep. Im getting mouthy here so Im gonna stop.
And take your time :-)
Yours truly,
Ebele
Well, to business.
Amanda, is she a magician, or a commoner?
In the end of AoS Bartimaeus took her guise and tricked Lovelace, we all know that. But in the beginning, when Bart was stealing the amulet he dwelled on taking N's guise but said that he needs the person's birth name to become them, this is how he becomes Ptolemy and Kitty later on. So if 'Amanda' was her real name, that means she can't be a magician, but how can she be a commoner if she's rich? I mean, she's having this big party at her place, and all the cool kids from the government are invited... what's up with that? Why would the PM go to a ball in a commoner's house? Also, if she is a commoner, why would Lovelace be with her?
So who is she?
By the way, I live in Israel, and I know theres a Hebrew translation but I still read the books in English, the original is far better I always say, with the true touch of the author. Yep, and also, (as far as I know) your books are not very well known in Israel, at least, Im the only one who read them in my school and weve got this book report we have to do in English, so naturally Im doing mine on AoS, (my fav), other kids are just taking books form the school library. Ive asked around and saw that all the other kids think this report is torture because the only English books our library has are kitsch romantic novels written like, a hundred years ago(!) nothing against old novels, its just not very suitable for non English speaker kids. So I recommended Bartimaeus trilogy and the library bought it! So now Im happy and I just thought you might want to know Im doing some advertisement for you here :D spreading the word!
Yep. Im getting mouthy here so Im gonna stop.
And take your time :-)
Yours truly,
Ebele
Right... so signature eh?